Remove supreme-court-affirms-death-penalty-with-a-batson-dissent
article thumbnail

Supreme Court affirms death penalty, with a Batson dissent

At the Lectern

The Supreme Court today affirms the death sentence in People v. The court’s opinion is authored by Justice Mariano-Florentino Cuéllar. Justice Goodwin Liu dissents, claiming Batson / Wheeler error, named after U.S. Justice Goodwin Liu dissents, claiming Batson / Wheeler error, named after U.S.

article thumbnail

Ninth Circuit says a Supreme Court decision rejecting a Batson/Wheeler claim in the affirmance of a death sentence was unreasonable

At the Lectern

Broomfield affirming a district court grant of habeas corpus relief to a prisoner whose death sentence for a 1984 murder the Supreme Court had upheld ( People v. However, even applying a highly deferential standard of review, the district court and the Ninth Circuit disagreed. Jackson (1996) 13 Cal.4th

Insiders

Sign Up for our Newsletter

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Trending Sources

article thumbnail

The California Supreme Court and the SCOTUS October 2021 term

At the Lectern

How did the California Supreme Court do at the U.S. Supreme Court during the latter’s most recent term, which ended last week? Moriana , the Court disapproved one rule stated years earlier in Iskanian v. (See: See: SCOTUS disapproves California Supreme Court decision.). Here’s a look.

Court 58
article thumbnail

Supreme Court allows discovery of prosecutor’s notes relevant to a Batson/Wheeler challenge

At the Lectern

Rejecting an attorney-work-product claim, the Supreme Court today in People v. Superior Court (Jones) upholds a death row inmate’s right to review a prosecutor’s jury selection notes. Eight years ago, the court rejected the direct automatic appeal of the inmate’s death sentence. ( People v.

Court 49
article thumbnail

Death sentences affirmed despite disagreement on stun belt use and Batson

At the Lectern

The Supreme Court today affirms the three death penalties in People v. Justice Goodwin Liu dissents. He also disagrees with the majority’s holding that the defendants did not make a prima facie showing of Batson error. See, e.g., here , here , and here.).

Court 53
article thumbnail

Ninth Circuit closes habeas door to one California condemned inmate, cracks it open for another

At the Lectern

On Friday, the Ninth Circuit ruled on habeas corpus relief for two different prisoners whose death sentences had been affirmed by the California Supreme Court. In one case, the federal appeals court upheld the denial of a habeas petition. Supreme Court law. Supreme Court case law — Flowers v.

Court 49