article thumbnail

Latest Dominion Doc Dump Shows Big Mens Rea Energy At Fox

Above The Law

The post Latest Dominion Doc Dump Shows Big Mens Rea Energy At Fox appeared first on Above the Law. Don't ya hate it when your group chats leak? Government Defamation Dominion Voting Systems Fox News

Mens Rea 100
article thumbnail

US Supreme Court rules prosecutors must prove doctors knowingly prescribed drugs illegally to secure unlawful distribution conviction

JURIST

Uncategorized doctors Domestic mens rea narcotics opioids overprescription prescription drugs scotus US Supreme Court

Mens Rea 185
Insiders

Sign Up for our Newsletter

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

article thumbnail

India: Would Lack Of ‘Mens Rea' Constitute Medical Negligence? Supreme Court Says YES - S.S. Rana & Co. Advocates

Mondaq

To declare any act as a criminal offence, it must consist of two elements - Actus Reus (a guilty act) and Mens Rea (intention or knowledge of wrong-doing

article thumbnail

Biden Critics Say Change to Trump ‘Mens Rea’ Reform Endangers Innocent

The Crime Report

article thumbnail

UK: Tom McNeill On Corporate Criminal Liability (Video) - BCL Solicitors LLP

Mondaq

BCL senior associate Tom McNeill is interviewed discussing the shifting UK corporate criminal liability landscape and applying the regulatory approach to Mens Rea offences

article thumbnail

Panel Holds that Ohio Aggravated Burglary Statute Does Not Count as Predicate Violent Felony under ACCA. 

SquirePattonBoggs

2022), the Sixth Circuit read Borden as requiring a purposeful or knowing mens rea for offenses deemed violent felony predicate offenses. Borden ’s mens rea requirement mattered here because, on its face, R.C. Co-authored by: Stephanie A. Darville & Shams H.

article thumbnail

Texas man sues 3 women for allegedly aiding his ex-wife obtain abortion medication

JURIST

Furthermore, according to Silva, all the defendants knew they were aiding in a murder and had the mens rea (guilty mind) needed to trigger the application of both statutes.

Mens Rea 104
article thumbnail

Subjective intent of wrongdoing required to convict doctors under Controlled Substances Act

SCOTUSBlog

In arguing a subjective standard is required, the charged doctors and other advocates emphasized longstanding rules about the presumption of mens rea (a guilty state of mind) for criminal offenses.

article thumbnail

Report examines challenges to prosecuting police for civil rights violations

JURIST

It compares this standard, which incorporates a subjective element with a high threshold for proof into the requisite mens rea, with both “knowingly” and “recklessly.”

Mens Rea 211
article thumbnail

Pakistan dispatch: persecution of religious minorities continues under current blasphemy law

JURIST

Every clause in the blasphemy law was modified or changed when Zia was leader, and the intent or mens rea requirement was completely removed. Law students and law graduates in Pakistan are reporting for JURIST on events in that country impacting its legal system.

Mens Rea 264
article thumbnail

Upcoming Supreme Court Oral Arguments in IP & Tech Cases

Patently O

The question is whether his intent (mens rea) matters, or can he be convicted based only upon the reasonably perceived threat of the recipient.).

article thumbnail

US Supreme Court rules reckless offenses do not qualify as ‘violent felony’

JURIST

Justice Elena Kagan, joined by Justices Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Neil Gorsuch, wrote the opinion of the court, concluding that any offense with a mens rea or mental state of recklessness does not qualify as a violent felony under the ACCA. The US Supreme Court on Thursday overturned a ruling by the US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit that “reckless” crimes qualify as violent felonies for purposes of the Armed Career Criminal Act (ACCA).

Felony 119
article thumbnail

Amid overdose crisis, court will weigh physician intent in “pill mill” prosecutions and more under the Controlled Substances Act

SCOTUSBlog

The government, in turn, focuses on the structure of the CSA — the words denoting mens rea, “knowingly or intentionally,” come after the exception clause at issue and so, the government argues, do not apply to it.

article thumbnail

Canada Supreme Court hands down varied rulings on firearm-related mandatory minimums

JURIST

Hilbach , the court considered whether the five- and four-year mandatory minimums for two men convicted of armed robbery with a firearm were constitutional.

Mens Rea 104
article thumbnail

Could the Road to an AKS Violation Be Paved with Good Intentions? Pfizer Asks SCOTUS

FDA Law Blog

The Second Circuit’s Interpretation of the AKS and its Mens Rea Element. The Court instead interpreted the term, as used in the AKS, to mean an intentional violation of a known legal duty, but concluded that “the mens rea element goes no further.” By Sophia R.

article thumbnail

No sentencing enhancements for recklessness convictions under federal Armed Career Criminal Act

SCOTUSBlog

The ACCA, in Borden’s view, required a higher culpable state of mind, or mens rea , than recklessness. A mens rea of purpose equates to a consciously desirable outcome. Share In Borden v.

article thumbnail

Good Doc, Bad Doc: Supreme Court Finds Prescriber Knowledge Counts

FDA Law Blog

Writing for the majority, Justice Breyer stated that the Court holds that the statutory language “knowing or intentionally” ( mens rea) applies to the “except as authorized“ clause under section 841, meaning that if the prescriber was otherwise authorized to issue the prescription (e.g.,

article thumbnail

J&K&L HC quashed defamation complaint filed against media-persons

LexForti

It also highlighted that mens rea, a condition precedent to constitute the offence of defamation, had been absent in order to prove the intention or knowledge on part of accused to harm the reputation of complainant.

article thumbnail

Second Circuit Agrees that Copay Assistance Programs May Violate the Anti-Kickback Statute

FDA Law Blog

The Court instead concluded that the term, as used in the AKS, is “more accurately understood as a voluntary, intentional violation of a known legal duty…the mens rea element goes no further” (internal quotations omitted). By Sophia R. Gaulkin & Alan M.

Statute 98
article thumbnail

‘Search Warrants Rot Law Enforcement’: Paper

The Crime Report

It is imperative that evidence obtained through materially false statements in warrants be rejected regardless of the mens rea of the applicant,” Cook explained.

Mens Rea 125
article thumbnail

No Walk in the Park: JAMA Editorial Calls for More Park Prosecutions; We Disagree

FDA Law Blog

It’s a bedrock principle of criminal law that crimes require an actus reus (the prohibited act) and the requisite mens rea (mental state). By Jeffrey N.

article thumbnail

In opioids “pill mill” case, justices grapple with physician intent

SCOTUSBlog

Several justices asked first, whether, for every element of a crime, the government had to prove mens rea; and second, what precise burden remains on the government once a doctor puts forward lack of criminal intent as a defense. Share.

article thumbnail

Argument analysis: Justices doubt FTC’s authority to compel monetary relief

SCOTUSBlog

If you’re arguing on behalf of a federal regulatory agency’s authority to protect consumers from businesses and Justice Stephen Breyer sets his face against you, then chances are your day is not going well.

Mens Rea 109
article thumbnail

New Orleans Police Seek Arrest of Dispatcher Under Novel Criminal Charge

JonathanTurley

The mens rea element is merely eliminating involuntary failures like illness or force in the failure to perform. New Orleans Police Department. The New Orleans Police Department has put out an arrest warrant for one of its own in a case with an unusual criminal charge.

article thumbnail

Venue (and Changing Venue) in Criminal Trade Secret Cases

Patently O

Of these, elements 1 and 4 are mens rea elements rather than conduct elements and so the 11th Circuit found them irrelevant to the venue question. by Dennis Crouch. Timothy Smith v. US , 21-1576 (Supreme Court 2022).

article thumbnail

How the present Laws would have dealt with the Uchiha Massacre?

LexForti

Whatever the mens-rea may be, the actus-reus was the total elimination of a clan. SPOILER ALERTS. Who is Itachi Uchiha? Itachi Uchiha.

article thumbnail

Meeting of the Minds: The Price of Recklessness: Disgorgement of Pro?ts in a Post-Romag World

The IP Law Blog

While the argument that “principles of equity” includes a willfulness requirement would not “directly contradict the statute’s other, express mens rea provisions or render them wholly superfluous[,]. ©2021. Published in Landslide , Vol. 13, No.

article thumbnail

A Case of Hope Over Experience: The J6 Referral Falls Short of a Credible Criminal Case

JonathanTurley

That is a far cry from evidence showing mens rea — “guilty mind.” This week the January 6th Committee voted to make criminal referrals to the Justice Department, including the proposed indictment of former President Donald Trump.

article thumbnail

Last-chance Hearing: Jan. 6 Committee Has Yet To Establish A Criminal Case Against Trump

JonathanTurley

It is the type of evidence used to show mens rea — “guilty mind.” C-Span Screengrad. Below is my column in the Hill on today’s final scheduled hearing of the J6 Committee.

article thumbnail

“Without any Doubt, Beyond a Reasonable Doubt, Beyond any Doubt”: Tribe Declares Trump Committed Attempted Murder

JonathanTurley

Even then, it can be difficult since attempted murder requires proof that the defendant “must have taken a substantial step towards that crime, and must also have had the requisite mens rea.”

article thumbnail

A Criminologist Assesses the ‘Racketeer-in-Chief’

The Crime Report

In a forthcoming (May 2022) book, Criminology on Trump, I have marshalled the mens rea type of evidence that I hope prosecutors and the Department of Justice will consider in charging Trump and his associates with a variety of white-collar crimes.

Mens Rea 136
article thumbnail

Detailed Analysis of POCSO Act, 2012

LexForti

Teesha Deb (National Law University, Orissa). In this Article, the author has given a detailed analysis of POCSO Act. The author is associated to the National Law University, Orissa. INTRODUCTION.