DC Circuit rules Dish Network must defend itself against whistleblower lawsuit News
renateko / Pixabay
DC Circuit rules Dish Network must defend itself against whistleblower lawsuit

US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit Tuesday ordered that Dish Network Corp. (Dish) must defend itself in a whistleblower False Claims Act lawsuit. The court found that a lower court decision to dismiss the case against Dish was wrong.

The suit against Dish was brought by Vermont National Telephone Co. (Vermont National) on behalf of the US government under the False Claims Act. The False Claims Act makes any person who knowingly submitted false claims to the government liable for double the government’s damages plus a penalty of $2,000 for each false claim. A qui tam action under the False Claims Act allows individuals or entities with evidence a party has defrauded the government to sue the wrongdoer party on behalf of the US government. 

Vermont National alleges that Dish defrauded the US government of $3.3 billion by manipulating Federal Communications Commission (FCC) rules and falsely certifying their eligibility for discounts on spectrum licenses through the use of fictional small businesses.

A lower court found that the action against Dish was barred by a government-action bar. The government-action bar prohibits plaintiffs from bringing a suit which contains allegations at the heart of another government civil or administrative suit. The DC Circuit reversed the lower court. The DC Circuit found that the allegations against Dish were sufficient to afford Dish “the opportunity to prepare a response and to warrant further judicial process.”

THIS DAY @ LAW

Line of Demarcation divides the New World between Spain and Portugal

On May 4, 1493, Pope Alexander VI promulgated the Line of Demarcation, dividing the New World between Spain and Portugal in response the return of Christopher Columbus from his discovery of the American continents. However, neither country was entirely satisfied with the placement of the Line. A year later on June 7, 1494, the two nations signed the Treaty of Tordesillas, which moved the Line of Demarcation further west, giving Portugal claim to Brazil.

Kent State student shootings precipitated lawsuits

On May 4, 1970, National Guardsmen at Kent State University opened fire on students protesting the US invasion of Cambodia, killing four.

Review a legal chronology of the Kent State shootings, from May 5, 1970 (the day the FBI investigation started) to January 4, 1979 (the day the state of Ohio reached an out-of-court settlement for $675,000 with victims and relatives of victims).